<< Chapter < Page Chapter >> Page >

Preview the unit: content and habits of thinking

Find time throughout the unit to return to the Content and Habits of Thinking . Ask students to talk about the content they have learned thus far and the habits they are acquiring.You can also call their attention to the Teacher Resource poster, Language of Persuasion , displayed in the room and ask: How could you use this poster? These are important ways to help students self-manage their learning.

Read to get the gist: "ain't i a woman?"

Give students some contextual information about the speech they are about to read. Explain that it was delivered at a two-day women's rights convention in 1851 in Akron, Ohio. Many speakers, among them clergy members, argued against equal rights for women, claiming the superiority of men and using the Bible as evidence to defend their claims. Then Sojourner Truth, who had not been invited to the convention, stood up to speak without notes or a written text. Give no other background on Sojourner Truth; background will be built through answering the comprehension questions.

Write the following comprehension questions on the board:

  • What is the speech about? What is the issue?
  • Who is the speaker? What do we know about her? How do we know?

Ask students to read the speech silently.

NOTE: It is important not to read the speech aloud or have students listen to it on tape at this point. Later in the unit, students will be asked to deliver this speech themselves. If they hear it delivered by a professional now, they may view that reading as the correct way to deliver the speech rather than as one person's interpretation.

Discuss comprehension questions

Ask students to turn to a partner and discuss the comprehension questions for about three minutes. Then have a whole group discussion on the questions. Press students to cite evidence from the text to support their answers.

Give students an opportunity to ask any questions they have about the speech, the context, Sojourner Truth, etc. Encourage students to answer each other's questions; step in to provide additional information. Remind students of what you told them earlier about Sojourner Truth speaking out at this convention without notes. Explain to them that speaking without notes and advance preparation is called impromptu speaking.

Consider charting responses to the comprehension questions. A visual record is helpful for all students, especially English learners.
The following websites provide additional information about Sojourner Truth http://www.lkwdpl.org/wihohio/trut-soj.htm and http://www.sojournertruth.org/Default.htm
Have students generate questions they might ask and where they might do research to find out how different versions of the speech came to be recorded. There is considerable controversy over the accuracy of all of the versions cited in various historical and contemporary sources.

Ask students to listen, inside and outside of school, over the next few days, for issues that affect a group of people, possibly people in their community (school, neighborhood, city, region) which they could speak out about in order to inspire change in their peers' beliefs or actions.

Talk with students about how they might come up with issues (e.g., watch, read, or listen to the news; pay attention to what people around them say needs to be changed; consider which of their own concerns are also of concern to others).

Explain to students that they will plan and deliver two speeches in this unit. Point out that this will build on the work students did with advocacy in 9th grade. The issues the class comes up with will be what they choose from as topics for their speeches. One of the speeches they will plan and deliver in 20 minutes with a partner; the other speech they will have two days to plan on their own. With that in mind, students should look for two different types of topics: (1) those that can be argued using the students' own experience as evidence, and (2) those that require print/media research. Suggest that students make notes in their Reader's/ Writer's Notebooks about the issues they are considering.

Ask students to give examples of issues they might know enough about that they could persuade others without library research, and those that will require research. Students should consider their audience (their peers), understanding that whether or not research is needed will depend on the audience's knowledge of the issue as well as the students' own.

The class will discuss their ideas in a later lesson in the unit. Every student should have at least two issues to share that day.

Get Jobilize Job Search Mobile App in your pocket Now!

Get it on Google Play Download on the App Store Now




Source:  OpenStax, Selected lessons in persuasion. OpenStax CNX. Apr 07, 2008 Download for free at http://cnx.org/content/col10520/1.2
Google Play and the Google Play logo are trademarks of Google Inc.

Notification Switch

Would you like to follow the 'Selected lessons in persuasion' conversation and receive update notifications?

Ask