0.3 Appendix

Examples of good practice

General ex. 1: question that encourages good discussion.

General ex. 2. use of student polls.

Examples of specific good clicker questions from range of courses.

Environmental science course

This question was presented during the class meeting AFTER students had completed and had returned to them a graded homework assignment in which they were asked to plot and interpret hydrologic data.

Clicker Question: Who knows more about a set of data?

Answer choices (results prior to discussion) :

1. the person collects it (~10%) ,
2. the person who plots it (~90%)

This clicker question was used as spring board into talking about the HW assignment. During the discussion students greatly changed their original opinion about who knew more about the data. That discussion then acted as segue into the next lecture topic on using hydrologic data to predict flooding.

Genetics course

A series of clicker questions can reveal that although students understand parts of a topic they still have misunderstandings about it.

Sister chromatids

1. Yes 100%
2. No

Do they have the same alleles?

1. Yes 100%
2. No

Homologous chromosomes

1. Yes 46%
2. No 54%

You grow sweet peas. One of your clients wants purple sweet peas for her wedding. Which two sweet peas should you cross in order to maximize the number of purple sweet peas in the next generation?

1. Purple CcPp x Purple CcPp
2. White CCpp x White ccPP
3. Purple CcPp x White ccPP
4. Purple CcPp x White CCpp

Introductory biology course.

1. A plasmid containing bacterial DNA and the gene for human growth hormone is introduced into a bacterium. Which growth hormone protein will be produced?
   1. A bacterial human growth hormone protein
   2. A human growth hormone protein
   3. A hybrid protein that is part human and part bacterial
   • Answer B
2. The production of a human protein in a bacterium can occur because:
   1. Humans and bacteria use exactly the same codons to specify each amino acid.
   2. Humans and bacteria use almost the same codons to specify each amino acids.
   3. Humans and bacteria use different codons to specify each amino acid, but there is enough similarity that the protein made in bacteria still works.
   • Answer A
3. Which of the following statements is true? All the somatic cells (the cells that do not contribute to the next generation) in your body contain:
   1. The same DNA sequences and the same proteins
   2. Different DNA sequences and different proteins
   3. The same DNA sequences but different proteins
   4. Different DNA sequences but the same proteins
   • Answer C
4. If an organism makes an abnormal protein, the error that led to this abnormality most likely originated
   1. during the replication of the corresponding gene.
   2. during transcription of the corresponding gene to make the corresponding mRNA.
   3. during translation of the corresponding mRNA to make the protein.
   • Answer A
5. Which of the following is a FALSE statement about bacteria and viruses?
   1. Viruses are cells.
   2. Viruses replicate inside human cells.
   3. Bacteria can replicate their own DNA.
   4. Viruses can have RNA as genetic material.
   • Answer A
6. Should you take an antibiotic if you have a viral infection?
   1. Yes, an antibiotic could kill the virus
   2. No, an antibiotic can only kill bacteria
   • Answer B
7. Draw a representation of the plasma membrane using circles and lines to represent the two “ends” of the phospholipids that comprise the membrane. Indicate the inside and outside of the cell with respect to the membrane. {Allow students to work on this drawing for a few minutes. Then, ask the following question:}
   
   Which of the following illustrations looks most like your own drawing (or looks correct now that you see it)?
   
   
   • Answer C

Physics course

1. You have a ring with a hole in it and a cylindrical plug that is exactly the same size when both are at room temperature. If you heat the ring, the plug will
   1. Fit through the hole more easily
   2. Be exactly the same size as before
   3. No longer fit through the hole
   This question can be followed by a demonstration involving an actual ring that you heat, if you choose.
2. When you close the switch, bulb # 2 will
   
   
   1. Get brighter
   2. Get dimmer
   3. Stay the same brightness
   4. Go out entirely

Geology course example – using learning difficulties (including misconceptions) in teaching:

Students often have difficulty identifying structural features which have undergone erosion (and with visualizations that are different than the standard textbook block diagrams). One common misconception is that structural features will follow topography; additionally, students generally don’t understand what kind of information is necessary to distinguish types of folds. Here’s a (faculty-developed) clicker question that promotes student examination and explanation of their own reasoning:

What additional information would you prefer in order to determine if the exposed geologic formations correspond to an anticline or a syncline?

1. Formation ages, rock compositions
2. Strike and dip measurements, formation ages
3. Rock compositions, fossil content
4. None of the above

Why this works